Parking Made Easy: A Case Study of Innovative Solution Implementation

Parking Made Easy: A Case Study of Innovative Solution Implementation

Parking Made Easy: A Case Study of Innovative Solution Implementation

Overview

Overview

For city residents, finding parking can be a major headache, wasting precious time and adding to traffic congestion. This case study explores the design of ParkEase, a parking app designed to simplify the process by integrating real-time data, intuitive navigation, and a streamlined booking process. Our app empowers drivers to find and secure parking spots effortlessly, transforming the parking experience and contributing to a smoother, more efficient urban environment.

Role

Role

UX Researcher
UX/UI Designer
Usability Tester

Team

Team

Solo (with feedback from mentor)

Tools

Tools

Figma
Notion

Duration

Duration

March 2024 - April 2024
5 Weeks (200 hours)

Background

Background

Every morning, navigating the congested streets in search of a parking spot felt like a daunting task. The frustration of circling blocks, missing appointments, and starting the day stressed inspired me to find a solution.

Initial Hypothesis

Initial Hypothesis

By providing seamless booking options, the parking app will significantly reduce the time and effort drivers expend searching for parking, thereby enhancing overall urban mobility and satisfaction levels.

THE DESIGN PROCESS

THE DESIGN PROCESS

Designing a User-Focused Research Plan

Designing a User-Focused Research Plan

With a hypothesis in mind, I knew that the key to success lay in understanding the experiences of real users. I designed a research plan to gather insights directly from the users.

Research Objectives: We believe that the lack of seamless booking options is the primary pain point for drivers seeking parking. To confirm this and discover any other daily frustrations drivers face, we created a research plan to collect insights directly from those who regularly experience the challenges of city parking.

Voices of the City

Voices of the City

Recruitment: To ensure diverse and relevant insights, I recruited 10 participants who use parking apps at least twice a month. These participants represented a mix of age groups, professions, and driving habits, providing a holistic view of the user base.

Interview Process: Conducting user interviews is both an art and a science. I crafted a semi-structured interview guide to balance consistency with the flexibility to explore unexpected insights.

Insights: As the interviews unfolded, a narrative began to emerge. Contrary to my initial hypothesis, only 10% of participants mentioned issues with seamless booking options. Instead, a clear picture of their pain points crystallized:

100%

100%

100%

of participants expressed frustration with having to roam around in traffic to find parking spots as a significant pain point

70%

70%

70%

of participants cited the absence of accurate, real-time availability updates about parking spots and their prices.

60%

60%

60%

of users reported occasional difficulties in extending parking times through existing apps.

10%

10%

10%

of participants did ever experience the problem of seamless booking options

The Turning Point - My hypothesis was wrong

The Turning Point - My hypothesis was wrong

My hypothesis was quickly proven wrong when 10% of participants did ever experience the problem of seamless booking options. From this experience, I gained a deeper level of understanding of the need to make evidence-based decisions to ensure a usable design.

This was the most significant part of this project, because it allowed me to 1.) Confirm my hypothesis, and 2.) Further explore the problem space. Though my hypothesis was incorrect, new problems surfaced from speaking with users, marking the pivot in this design

My hypothesis was quickly proven wrong when 10% of participants did ever experience the problem of seamless booking options. From this experience, I gained a deeper level of understanding of the need to make evidence-based decisions to ensure a usable design.

This was the most significant part of this project, because it allowed me to 1.) Confirm my hypothesis, and 2.) Further explore the problem space. Though my hypothesis was incorrect, new problems surfaced from speaking with users, marking the pivot in this design

My hypothesis was quickly proven wrong when 10% of participants did ever experience the problem of seamless booking options. From this experience, I gained a deeper level of understanding of the need to make evidence-based decisions to ensure a usable design.

This was the most significant part of this project, because it allowed me to 1.) Confirm my hypothesis, and 2.) Further explore the problem space. Though my hypothesis was incorrect, new problems surfaced from speaking with users, marking the pivot in this design

Persona helped me gather and prioritize the data

Persona helped me gather and prioritize the data

To consolidate the findings, I developed user personas representing the habits, motivations, goals, frustrations, and needs of our target users. An empathy map helped further understand the context and nuances of their experiences.

Pivoting Based on Insights

Pivoting Based on Insights

Realizing my hypothesis was incorrect marked a turning point. Instead of focusing on seamless booking, I needed to address the real issues: finding parking spots and obtaining accurate information. This insight led to a significant pivot in my design approach.

Realizing my hypothesis was incorrect marked a turning point. Instead of focusing on seamless booking, I needed to address the real issues: finding parking spots and obtaining accurate information. This insight led to a significant pivot in my design approach.

Realizing my hypothesis was incorrect marked a turning point. Instead of focusing on seamless booking, I needed to address the real issues: finding parking spots and obtaining accurate information. This insight led to a significant pivot in my design approach.

Redefining The Problem

Redefining The Problem

Redefining The Problem

How can we help users swiftly locate and reserve parking spots in urban areas?

How can we help users swiftly locate and reserve parking spots in urban areas?

The Problem

Users waste valuable time and energy navigating through congested city streets in search of available parking spaces, leading to frustration and delays in their daily routines.

The Problem

Users waste valuable time and energy navigating through congested city streets in search of available parking spaces, leading to frustration and delays in their daily routines.

The Solution

Implement real-time parking availability updates and price indicators to empower users with accurate information, enabling them to efficiently locate and reserve parking spots without the hassle of aimless driving.

The Solution

Implement real-time parking availability updates and price indicators to empower users with accurate information, enabling them to efficiently locate and reserve parking spots without the hassle of aimless driving.

Developing User-Centric Solutions

Developing User-Centric Solutions

Armed with these insights, I began planning new features to address the identified pain points.

Key Features Planned:

  • Real-Time Updates: Provided accurate, real-time information on parking availability and prices using GPS and IoT technology.

  • Enhanced Search: Allowed users to filter results by location, price, and availability.

  • Easy Extension: Simplified the process of extending parking times to reduce user frustration.

Armed with these insights, I began planning new features to address the identified pain points.

Key Features Planned:

  • Real-Time Updates: Provided accurate, real-time information on parking availability and prices using GPS and IoT technology.

  • Enhanced Search: Allowed users to filter results by location, price, and availability.

  • Easy Extension: Simplified the process of extending parking times to reduce user frustration.

Armed with these insights, I began planning new features to address the identified pain points.

Key Features Planned:

  • Real-Time Updates: Provided accurate, real-time information on parking availability and prices using GPS and IoT technology.

  • Enhanced Search: Allowed users to filter results by location, price, and availability.

  • Easy Extension: Simplified the process of extending parking times to reduce user frustration.

Mapping the User Flow

Mapping the User Flow

Mapping out the user flow helped visualize how to incorporate these features into the app. This user flow acted as a blueprint for designing the app's interface and functionality, ensuring each step aligned with the user's journey.

Bringing the ideas to life

Bringing the ideas to life

Brainstorming and Design: I brainstormed ideas for the visual layout and functionality, drawing inspiration from popular navigation and booking apps. The goal was to create a familiar yet innovative design.

Iterative Design Process: Utilizing user research insights as a guiding framework, I iteratively refined the design to ensure it seamlessly aligned with the user flow. This approach ensured the design met user expectations and optimized usability.

Let's explore the solutions

Let's explore the solutions

By focusing on consistency, and visual storytelling, I crafted a user interface that enhances usability and engagement. Throughout this journey, I learned the importance of iterative design, incorporating user feedback to refine the final product. This experience underscored the significance of embracing feedback and striving for excellence in user experience design.

Onboarding and Sign In

Onboarding and Sign In

Onboarding guides users seamlessly through the app's features, ensuring a smooth start to their parking experience. The sign-in screen offers secure access, enabling users to quickly log in and access personalized features,.

Home

Home

The homepage provides instant access to nearby parking options with key details, simplifying the search process. Real-time updates and notifications ensure users can easily find and reserve parking.

Parking Details

Parking Details

With clear visuals and essential details such as location, availability, and pricing, users can quickly assess parking options, reducing search time and frustration.

Select Date, Time & Slot

Select Date, Time & Slot

The select date, time and parking slot screens provide users with effortless scheduling for their parking needs. With intuitive controls and real-time availability updates, users can conveniently choose their desired time slot.

Barcode and Navigation

Barcode and Navigation

E-receipt page offers users a convenient digital record of their parking transaction, complete with a scannable barcode and detailed information. The barcode simplifies future access, while the Navigate page provides users with a preview of their path to the parking destination through an interactive map.

Parking Timer

Parking Timer

With a clear countdown and pertinent information, users can efficiently manage their time and parking needs. Additionally, it allows users to extend their parking time seamlessly.

Usability Testing

Usability Testing

Usability Testing

Real feedback, real-time. 

Real feedback, real-time. 

I conducted usability testing with 4 participants representing the target user demographic. The testing sessions provided real-time feedback on the app's usability.

50%

50%

50%

struggled to find parking within their desired price range, suggesting the need for price filters.

75%

75%

75%

highlighted the absence of a cancellation feature as a major limitation.

100%

100%

100%

found the reservation process efficient and user-friendly.

75%

75%

75%

appreciated the clear and helpful navigation instructions.

Priority Revisions (2nd Iteration)

Priority Revisions (2nd Iteration)

Based on the feedback, the second iteration focused on these key features:

Adding Filters

Adding Filters

Users can filter by location, price range, review ratings, and facilities like CCTV, Elevator, and Guarded. Sorting options were also introduced for personalized searches.

Cancellation

Cancellation

Integrated a cancellation option to enhance user convenience.

Key Learnings

Key Learnings

Key Learnings

Always conduct user interviews (or the appropriate research methodologies to test hypotheses)!

Always conduct user interviews (or the appropriate research methodologies to test hypotheses)!

Although it felt discouraging when my hypothesis was proved wrong, I'm glad that I found out in the very early phase of the project, rather than later. It taught me the importance of making evidence-based and data-driven decisions. The research phase of the design process truly builds the foundation of the design -  from testing the hypothesis, to collecting users' motivations, goals, and frustrations, it aids tremendously in exploring and understanding the problem space of the given topic. From this experience, I have gained a deeper level of appreciation and understanding of the ways UX is rooted in research and discovery. 

Next Steps

Next Steps

Next Steps

Conducting additional user interviews. 

Conducting additional user interviews. 

To really bring this point home, I would conduct further interviews to speak with more users about their experience with parking apps, as a next step. I would want to confirm two things: 

1. Was this the right audience for the problem I was initially trying to solve? (In other words, was my sample size too small?)

    2.  Are there any other frustrations that users are experiencing that are UX-related? 

Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts

Final Thoughts

Reflecting on the value of added feature. 

Reflecting on the value of added feature. 

With my initial hypothesis proved invalid, and due to the time restrictions and scope of this project, I proceeded to pivot my design to address a prevalent problem identified by 70% of users: the absence of real-time updates on parking availability and prices. Though I have confidence that my feature provides some measurable value, if I had extra time and resources, I would have searched for a more prevalent problem among users, so that my design could add maximal value and benefit. In addition to conducting more user interviews, I would have explored for other problems by analyzing user feedback and conducting secondary research online.

Let’s Collaborate

Paresh Thakkar

©

Paresh Thakkar

2024

Let’s
Collaborate

©

Paresh Thakkar

2024

Let’s
Collaborate

Paresh Thakkar

©

Paresh Thakkar

2024